Indoor air, 1970s–1980s
Sick Building Syndrome: What 1970s–80s Research Found About Indoor Air
By Jonathan Hernandez, President of Daytona Restoration, LLC, and an industrial hygienist. This is a summary of public research. It is not a Daytona project, not a diagnosis, and not medical advice. If you have symptoms, see a physician.
Tighter buildings after the energy crisis
The 1973 oil embargo pushed building practice toward using less energy. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s 1991 fact sheet on sick building syndrome says that earlier ventilation practice had been about 15 cubic feet per minute of outdoor air per person, mainly to dilute body odor, and that energy-conservation measures after the embargo called for cutting that outdoor air to 5 cubic feet per minute per person. EPA wrote that those lower rates were, in many buildings, not enough for health and comfort, and that inadequate ventilation is thought to be an important factor when occupants report sick-building complaints. EPA, Indoor Air Facts No. 4 (revised), February 1991.
ASHRAE’s own later account of Standard 62 matches that history with dates. The first edition, in 1973, required 15 cubic feet per minute of outdoor air per person in offices. After the 1970s oil crisis, the 1981 edition put energy first and cut the nonsmoking-office rate to 5 cubic feet per minute per person. Complaints and indoor-air concerns led the 1989 edition to raise the office rate to 20 cubic feet per minute per person. ASHRAE Journal, November 2022. A 2015 review of the same standard gives the 1981 nonsmoking-office figure as 2.5 liters per second per person, about 5 cubic feet per minute, and says the decrease was motivated in part by energy use. Persily, 2015.
The World Health Organization’s 1983 report said higher energy costs had brought a tendency to reduce ventilation. It described many of the buildings under discussion as energy-efficient, relatively warm, and wrapped in an airtight envelope. In the United States, it noted, the windows often could not be opened. Those buildings usually had a forced ventilation system that recirculated part of the air. WHO Regional Office for Europe, 1983.
What WHO, EPA, and NIOSH did in the early 1980s
WHO did not invent the problem in 1983. The Regional Office for Europe convened a working group in Nördlingen on 8–11 June 1982 and published the report in 1983 as Indoor air pollutants: exposure and health effects (EURO Reports and Studies 78). That report uses the name “sick building syndrome.” It says the first such buildings were recognized before 1960, and that case reports had increased in several countries, particularly during the six years before the meeting. Symptoms reported from Scandinavia and the United States included eye, nose, and throat irritation, dry mucous membranes and skin, mental fatigue, headache, cough, hoarseness, wheezing, nausea, and dizziness. The report also says those symptoms are common in any population, so a single person is hard to tie to a building, and that knowledge of the causes was fragmentary. WHO, 1983.
EPA’s 1991 fact sheet adds a figure from a 1984 WHO committee report: that report suggested up to 30 percent of new and remodeled buildings worldwide may be the subject of excessive indoor-air complaints. That is a 1984 suggestion about complaints in new and remodeled buildings. It is not a count of Utah buildings, and it is not a current rate. EPA, 1991. The meeting EPA is pointing at is WHO’s August 1984 indoor-air meeting in Stockholm. WHO, 1984.
NIOSH, part of CDC, was already going into offices. Its January 1987 guidance says investigators had answered indoor-air complaints since 1971, that 446 indoor-air health hazard evaluations had been done through December 1986, and that the number rose sharply after 1979. NIOSH gave two likely reasons: more energy-conservation measures, and more worker awareness. It also said the set of buildings is not a statistical sample of all offices. The complaints were often nonspecific — headache, irritated eyes, skin, sinuses, throat — and often eased when people were away from the office. NIOSH, January 1987.
A companion NIOSH report tallied 356 indoor-air evaluations finished from 1971 through December 1985. In that set, NIOSH classed about half as inadequate ventilation. About 19 percent were contaminants from inside the building, 11 percent from outside, 4 percent from the building fabric, 5 percent biological contamination, and 11 percent unknown. Those shares describe the buildings NIOSH was asked to visit, not every American office. Wallingford, NIOSH, 1987.
EPA studied its own headquarters in 1989 after employees raised indoor-air concerns. A February 1989 questionnaire went to the staff of three headquarters complexes. About 3,955 of an estimated 4,900 employees answered, an 81 percent response. The first volume is a survey of what people reported. It does not include a physician’s diagnosis, and it does not, by itself, name a cause. EPA headquarters employee survey, 1989.
Sick building syndrome and building-related illness
EPA uses sick building syndrome for acute discomfort that seems linked to time in a building when no specific illness or cause can be identified. The complaints may be in one room or through the whole building. Indicators EPA lists include headache, irritation of the eyes, nose, or throat, dry cough, dry or itchy skin, dizziness, nausea, trouble concentrating, fatigue, and sensitivity to odors, with relief for most people soon after they leave. EPA also says complaints can come from an illness caught elsewhere, allergies, job stress, or other factors, even while indoor air can cause or worsen symptoms. EPA, 1991.
Building-related illness is the other term. EPA uses it when symptoms of a diagnosable illness are identified and can be attributed to airborne building contaminants. Recovery can take longer after the person leaves. Legionnaires’ disease is the example people know, and it is not sick building syndrome. In July 1976, people who had attended an American Legion convention in Philadelphia developed pneumonia. The abstract of the December 1977 paper in the New England Journal of Medicine states that twenty-nine of 182 cases were fatal, that spread of the bacterium appeared to be airborne, and that exposure may have occurred in the lobby of the headquarters hotel or just outside it. That same abstract says the source of the bacterium was not found. The 182 cases and 29 deaths are that paper’s count, not a figure from the CDC museum account. Fraser and others, New England Journal of Medicine, 1977. CDC later identified the bacterium, Legionella pneumophila, and has described it as spread through the hotel’s air-conditioning system. CDC Museum, Legionnaires’ disease. EPA’s fact sheet lists Legionella as an indoor bacterium that has caused both Legionnaires’ disease and Pontiac fever, under biological contaminants, which is a different category from an unexplained sick-building complaint.
What the research pointed to
EPA’s fact sheet groups contributing factors this way. Inadequate ventilation, including an air system that does not actually deliver outdoor air to people. Chemical contaminants from indoors, including volatile organic compounds from adhesives, carpet, manufactured wood, copiers, pesticides, and cleaners, and formaldehyde among those compounds. Chemical contaminants from outdoors, such as vehicle exhaust pulled in through a badly placed intake. Biological contaminants: bacteria, molds, pollen, and viruses, which may grow in stagnant water in humidifiers and drain pans, or where water has collected on ceiling tile, carpet, or insulation. EPA says these can act together, along with temperature, humidity, and lighting, and that an investigation can still end without a specific cause.
WHO’s 1983 report is more cautious. It says the evidence on causes was fragmentary. It discusses volatile compounds from new materials and paints, formaldehyde and other irritants from furnishings and products, and thermal conditions. It separates a temporary pattern in new or newly remodeled buildings, in which symptoms often fade in about half a year, from buildings where symptoms last for years. NIOSH’s 1987 guidance says the largest category it saw was inadequate ventilation, then chemical contamination, then microbiological contamination. Microbiological problems in those investigations often traced to water-damaged carpets or furnishings, or standing water in ventilation equipment. NIOSH tied some of those exposures to diagnosable illnesses such as hypersensitivity pneumonitis, which is building-related illness, not the unexplained syndrome.
None of these sources say that mold, on its own, causes sick building syndrome. They do say moisture and biological growth belong on the list of things that can contaminate a building, and that the syndrome is the name for complaints that stay unexplained.
What this means in a Utah house or office
Utah buildings are not the 1980s office investigations. The useful part of that research, here, is simpler. Fresh air still matters. Water still matters. If a house or an office is musty, if a basement stays wet after snowmelt, or if growth is visible, the next step is to find the moisture and decide whether it needs drying, removal, or a sample. That is an inspection of the building. It is not a diagnosis of the people in it.
Mold inspection is the visit that decides whether a sample is worth taking. Mold testing is the laboratory sample, used when growth is hidden or someone needs a report. Mold remediation is the cleanup when material has to come out and the water has to stop. Air clearance testing is a later sample, after that work, and it is not automatic. Daytona Environmental does the testing. Daytona Restoration does the cleanup. Both are scheduled from 1010 North 500 East STE 200, North Salt Lake, UT 84054.
See a physician for symptoms. Do not use this history to decide whether a person is ill, and do not treat a musty room as proof of sick building syndrome.
Questions
When did the World Health Organization take up sick building syndrome?
A WHO Regional Office for Europe meeting in Nördlingen, Germany, on 8–11 June 1982 discussed the pattern and used the name “sick building syndrome.” WHO published that meeting as a report in 1983. The report said the first such buildings were recognized before 1960, and that case reports had increased, especially in the six years before the meeting.
Is sick building syndrome the same as a diagnosable building illness?
No. U.S. EPA uses sick building syndrome for comfort and health complaints that seem tied to time in a building when no specific illness or cause is identified, and that often ease after people leave. Building-related illness is the term EPA uses when a diagnosable illness is tied to a contaminant in the building air. Legionnaires’ disease is an example of the second kind, not of sick building syndrome.
Does mold cause sick building syndrome?
The sources do not say that mold, by itself, is the cause of sick building syndrome. EPA lists molds among biological contaminants that can grow where water has collected, and lists biological contamination as one contributing factor in indoor-air complaints. By EPA’s definition, sick building syndrome is the situation in which no specific cause has been identified. A musty or wet building is still a reason to look for moisture and growth.
What should I do if I feel sick in a building?
See a physician for symptoms. This page is building history, not a diagnosis and not medical advice. If the question is moisture, visible growth, or whether a Utah house or office needs an inspection, call Daytona or use the request form. We do not publish a price. You see the estimate before paid work starts.
Sources
- World Health Organization Regional Office for Europe. Indoor air pollutants: exposure and health effects. Report on a WHO meeting, Nördlingen, 8–11 June 1982. Copenhagen: WHO; 1983. EURO Reports and Studies 78.
- World Health Organization. Indoor air quality research. Report on a WHO meeting, Stockholm, 27–31 August 1984.
- U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. Indoor Air Facts No. 4 (revised): Sick Building Syndrome. February 1991.
- U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. Indoor Air Quality and Work Environment Study: EPA Headquarters Buildings. Volume I: Employee Survey. Questionnaire fielded February 1989.
- National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health. Guidance for Indoor Air Quality Investigations. Hazard Evaluations and Technical Assistance Branch. January 1987.
- Wallingford KM. NIOSH indoor air quality in office buildings. Technical report, 1987. Covers 356 evaluations from 1971 through December 1985.
- McNulty M. Increasing Ventilation. ASHRAE Journal. November 2022.
- Persily A. Challenges in Developing Ventilation and Indoor Air Quality Standards: The Story of ASHRAE Standard 62. Building and Environment. 2015.
- Fraser DW, Tsai TR, Orenstein W, and others. Legionnaires’ Disease: Description of an Epidemic of Pneumonia. New England Journal of Medicine. 1977;297:1189–1197. The abstract states: “Twenty-nine of 182 cases were fatal.” It also states that the source of the bacterium was not found.
- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Legionnaires’ disease. David J. Sencer CDC Museum.
Request an estimate.
For a musty or wet building, call (385) 255-7384 or send the form. The office is 1010 North 500 East STE 200, North Salt Lake, UT 84054. We do not publish a price. You see the estimate before paid work starts. Symptoms belong with a physician.